We make it simple to order your Thanksgiving menu in only 2 steps

Step 1: Download

Download and fill out the Thanksgiving PDF Order Sheet.

Step 2: Email, Fax or Call-In

Email a completed order sheet to holiday@butterfieldmarket.com or fax to 212-772-2506. You can call in your order at 212-772-8782 Ext. 3

Questions?

If you have any questions, please call us at 212-772 8782 Ext. 3 or email us at holiday@butterfieldmarket.com

Need help?

Serving Instructions

Continue Exploring

View Ingredients

Delivery Information

Butterfield delivers throughout Manhattan

We Cannot Deliver from 34th to 44th Street Between Broadway & 7th Avenue due to Thanksgiving Day Parade on Thursday

Uptown East

$30

Between 105th & 130th Street
Upper East Side

$20

Between 105th & 59th Street
Midtown East

$30

Between 59th & 36th Street
Downtown East

$40

Between 36th & 14th Street
Lower East

$50

Between 14th & Houston Street
Below Houston East

$60

Below Houston East
Uptown West

$40

Between 100th & 130th Street
West Side

$30

Between 100th & 50th Street
Downtown West

$55

Between 30th & 14th Street
Lower West

$60

Between 14th & Houston Street
Uptown East

$40

Between 105th & 130th Street
Upper East Side

$30

Between 105th & 59th Street
Midtown East

$40

Between 59th & 36th Street
Downtown East

$50

Between 36th & 14th Street
Lower East

$60

Between 14th & Houston Street
Below Houston East

$70

Below Houston East
Uptown West

$50

Between 100th & 130th Street
West Side

$50

Between 100th & 50th Street
Downtown West

$60

Between 30th & 14th Street
Lower West

$75

Between 14th & Houston Street

Outside the areas listed above?

Please call us at (212) 772 8782 ext. 3 for further information. Pick-ups can be made at Butterfield Kitchen located at 346 East 92nd St (between 1st & 2nd Ave).

Butterfield Catering

Our True Passion

Our Catering Division has become one of the leading caterers in Manhattan, offering a wide range of services-from private gatherings to large corporate events.

Executive Chef Jorge Flores

Our Kitchen

We want to provide food that is always fresh, delicious, and enticing. Focused on seasonal ingredients, locally sourced when possible.

Popular Questions

Where do you deliver and can I pick-up?

We deliver throughout Manhattan. Outer borough delivery is available upon request You may pick up your holiday order from our Kitchen at 346 East 92nd Street (between 1st and 2nd Avenue). If you are just picking up a dessert, you can also pick up from Butterfield Market at 1114 Lexington Avenue (between 77th & 78th).

When do I need to place my order?

For Thanksgiving orders, please call or email us by 5 pm on November 17th.

Will you be having a Thanksgiving tasting this year?

We will be having a complimentary tasting on Tuesday, November 14th from 3:30 PM to 6:30 PM at our Market. Please stop by!

Can I order items off our your standard catering menu?

For this holiday, only items off our thanksgiving menu will be available.

Can I specify what size turkey I want?

Our cooked turkeys come in one size (14-16 lbs), usually closer to 15 pounds.  However, you can order our easy-to-cook oven-ready turkeys by the pound (from 12-22 pounds).

Does my food come ready to serve?

Many dishes on our holiday menus need to be heated prior to serving. Check out our serving instructions here.

Can I heat up the food in the containers that they come in?

Some items come in aluminum pans which can go directly into the oven. Other items come in plastic containers. Please refer to heating instructions for more detail.

Can I make alterations to a recipe?

For Thanksgiving catering orders we can not make alterations to any recipes. Check out our ingredient list for dietary restrictions.

Can I hire waitstaff to help set-up and serve our meal?

Yes of course! Please call and speak to one of our catering coordinators about this service. (212) 772-8782 Ext. 3

Is there a delivery minimum?

No; there is no minimum order required for delivery.

Can I order off of the Thanksgiving Menu for an office event?

We actually have a Corporate Package designed for office events. Please contact us for more information.

Continue Exploring

View Ingredients

Are you Ready?

Place Your Order

Staffing

Rental Coordination

Event Management

Liquor & Bar Service

Butterfield can make your event as effortless as possible by providing experienced and professionally trained captains, waiters, bartenders and chefs. We can provide a full range of bar service packages including wine and beer, full bar and top shelf liquor. Coordination of event rentals are also available. Please call to find out more about our full service catering and party planning services.

Butterfield Catering

Thanksgiving orders must be placed by Friday November 17th at 5 pm

Staffing
  • Event Chef’s
  • Bartenders
  • Servers
Event Management
  • Venue Coordination
  • Event Planning
  • Floral
Rental Coordination
  • Flatware
  • Linens
  • Tables & Chairs
Liquor & Bar Service
  • Wine & Craft Beer
  • Full Bar Service
  • Top Shelf Liquor

Butterfield Catering

P. (212) 772 8782 Ext. 3
F. (212) 772 2506
E. catering@butterfieldmarket.com

Butterfield Market

1114 Lexington Ave NYC 10075
P. (212) 288 7800
F. (212) 288 6308
E. market@butterfieldmarket.com

Butterfield Kitchen

346 East 92nd Street NYC 10128
P. (212) 772 8782 Ext. 3
F. (646) 695 7135
E. kitchen@butterfieldmarket.com